It's basically a list of the negatives mentioned by each of 9 different reviewers. After playing the game on my friend's 360 for a few hours, I actually do agree with a good chunk of these negatives, and at the same time I can see that the game is definitely slightly over-hyped. Some of the points they bring up are a little dumb though. Still, it's an awesome game, and I'd like to thank Rockstar for doing what they do best.