Why people are so adamant about ATI/NVIDIA

Demonmerc

Newbie
Joined
Jul 11, 2003
Messages
404
Reaction score
0
Time and time again we read posts by people who FOR SURE know HL2 will run better on the 9800 or the 5900 and the other card plain SUCKS. These are $400 top-of-the-line cards that both handle wonderfully, HL2 isn't out yet, nor have driver updates been released. There is absoultely NO way to tell which card will be better exept by word-of-mouth. So why do people get so ticked off about them? The answer kids, is cognitive dissonance.

Cognitive dissonance is a psychological phenomenon which has two major effects on learning:

If someone is called upon to learn something which contradicts what they already think they know — particularly if they are committed to that prior knowledge — they are likely to resist the new learning.

If learning something has been difficult, uncomfortable, or even humiliating enough, people are not likely to admit that the content of what has been learned is not valuable. To do so would be to admit that one has been "had", or "conned".

The more difficult it is to get on a course, the more participants are likely to value it and view it favourably regardless of its real quality. Ditto, the more expensive it is.

There you have it. Because people spend so much money on gfx cards, they are assuming they are getting the best. When information arises that questions or contradicts this, they are skeptical of it, even hostile.

So when you read these kind of posts, just remember that they need a shrink :bounce:
 
Becuase gabe said so?.... and Ati has a nicer line of cards ATM ...if nvidia made nicer cards id buy one of those.

and dont we already have enough threads on this subject...christ look down a few......
 
At this point it comes to IQ, sure both cards are relativly even performance wise, but ATi DOES have siginicantly better presentation. Not to mention HL2 will be enhanced for ATi cards.
 
***FANBOY ALERT***

HL2 will not be enhanced for ATi cards. Both cards will have optimisations for them.
 
As it's the more powerful card at the moment and Gabe recommends a 9800PRO (someone who has probably played the game on both cards) then my money's on the 9800 PRO... I just have to get the money first. Should take me a fortnight or so to get it :D
 
Originally posted by Chris_D
As it's the more powerful card at the moment and Gabe recommends a 9800PRO (someone who has probably played the game on both cards) then my money's on the 9800 PRO... I just have to get the money first. Should take me a fortnight or so to get it :D

THEY PAY HIM. Omfg. They were at the Ati booth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Both top-of-the-line cards are essentially the same with minor increases or decreases. There should be no debate.
 
See! this thread too! the CONTAMINATION is everywhere! Seal the airlock doors! They must NOT get through!!!
 
I still have to go with the 9800 because gabe said it was better, no im not a fanboy, I have a geforce right now, heh I never even started with either, I had a matrox card to begin with :D
 
when u have someone such as Gabe reccommending a certain card, deal or no deal, pple are going to listen.

why? lets see.. he works for the company thats making the game.. and probably runs the game on both ATI and NVIDIA cards... and he would know the game best?

if pple are buying a card based solely on how it will run HL2, then MHO is they are wasting their money..

if ur spending $300-$400 of ur hard earned money, then u want the best performance for ALL the games u play.. at least thats the smart way of spending money and purchasing the best hardware for ur comp.
 
Originally posted by crabcakes66
Sorry the FX line of cards sucks. No fanboyism about it.

^ so true. If any of you cant accept that sometimes ATi is ahead and sometimes nvidia is ahead then that sucks for you.
 
ill transform into a nvidia fanboi....

GABE wAS talkin out of his ass when he said 9800 performed/looked better!!! I mean CMON! what does he know? i bet he is just sayin that for teh moneys and teh hoes. HE SUx!!
 
IMO the fx5900 is the ONLY fx card worth getting, but when you look at the radeon 9800 for 100 bucks cheaper, I think the choice is obvious, at least I did...
 
Originally posted by DjBourgeoisie
IMO the fx5900 is the ONLY fx card worth getting, but when you look at the radeon 9800 for 100 bucks cheaper, I think the choice is obvious, at least I did...

wow....alright.

The 5900ultra is a must have?...its only part of the biggest mistake nvidia made.

I hope in 2 1/2 years nvidia comes back to dominate, cause by then ill be done w/ my 9800pro.
 
Yup, same here, I never will focus on just one company, im not shallow towards vid cards, I have a nvidia right now, im swiching to ATI because they have better cards out now, i'll determine which is best in the next lineup.
 
nVidia is really sad. I was at Tom' Hardware site. nVidia is a disgrace. Sometimes, it's best to let the Canadians handle the graphics.
 
they are the same. seriously , I cant honestly recommend one over the other. Good lord this shitty thread makes my head hurt.
 
domenmerc, I'm very sorry about the previous posters. I see that you are not trying to make so much of a point about the dominance of graphic card companies but rather the complete stubborness most pc buyers (or customers in any other market) have when it comes to purchasing "the best". I would especially love you to apply this knowledge of phsycology on the debate of PC vs. console and other debates we have had with out any conclusion.
 
WTF??? How am i racist??

i was fixing your post because you said goos insted of good you ****ing dumb shit

now get the **** out of here im no where near a racist
 
Originally posted by Chris_D
No but you are a flamer.

I wouldnt flame anyone for not deserving it. This kid makes stupid polls and he deserves it....you know his threads suck, most ppl here even said that in his threads...yet he keeps making them.... Pointlessly
 
That's true. But I'd rather have a forum full of pointless threads, than a forum full of your abuses towards other people. There's better ways to conduct yourself than to put together a string of expletives and call someone a dumb shit.
 
Aren't we all?

But at the end of the day, this is supposed to be a community. I'm sure even though you're an agressive person you wouldn't walk around your local community, your neighborhood, hurling abuse at people that piss you off, would you?
We're all here just to talk about the game, the other games and the general aspects of them.
If Abomination was here, or if they had decent moderator coverage in his and Munro's absence, then the pointless threads would be sorted out by them. Until they're back, live with it.

:cheers: C'mon Hunter, you've not always been like this.
 
but this community isn't that, cough, uhh... bright. I get were ridic gets his rage lol.
 
They piss me off too. But I very rarely, if at all, resort to name calling and profanities. Flame them if you must, but do it in a nice way :)

/me just dies.

It's easier that way.
 
Originally posted by [Hunter]Ridic
WTF??? How am i racist??

i was fixing your post because you said goos insted of good you ****ing dumb shit

now get the **** out of here im no where near a racist
I h8 racists, but Hunter isn't one of them.
Chris_D: I haven't killed u have I? Being a flamer and all....
 
i hate racists as well, thats why i freaked out.
 
Treddyplop: Only stupid people kill me.
 
Back
Top