Disappointed with Stronghold 2

DEATH eVADER

Space Core
Joined
Nov 10, 2003
Messages
8,141
Reaction score
19
My intentions of buying this was down to the fact I had played the original and I enjoyed playing the game. Simple gameplay mechanics, yet in depth micro-management. Despite having a fixed-rotatable isometric graphics engine, it was a fun experience.

Comes along Stronghold 2, and I had to check it out. Even though it had a 3D graphics engine this time round, I wasn't going to buy it for that feature alone. Other gameplay features include more ways to defend your stronghold, new buildings, a new single-player campaign, cope with fires, plague, etc.

Come playing it, I felt I was handed a piece of sh*t.

- Steep (very steep) learning curve, both for the peaceful and military single player games, it is difficult to pass mission 3 for both gameplay types

- Multiplayer (more precisely Skirmish), was too compact, and clustered, and there was no way of having more than two people play at anyone time, otherwise it is difficult to gain any type of land and a foothold is generated very quickly for every player playing

- 3D engine was old and feeble and was not optimized. The animations and movements of the characters and siege weapons felt laggy and had fixed movement (think, a sprite that looked 3D)

-It looked like they had spent more time doing the cutscenes than the actual gameplay mechanics

-Some buildings I thought were not essential (They might of served som,e purpose in the peaceful campaign, but I didn't get to that point

-Earthquake+Meteor Shower+Acid+Microwaves= The type of fire you will be seeing ingame, at one point the amount of water wells I had outnumbered any other building (I literally had one well next to each building)





My Verdict

Stronghold= 8/10
Stronghold 2 = 4/10
 
Bait said:
R:TW ftw?

Yes, actually:thumbs:

Yeah, I never played the original but #2 is horrible. It seemed like a normal "expensive" game, but when you play it, it looks like a couple amature guys did it. Most HL2 RTS mods look more professional.
 
Bait said:
R:TW ftw?


Funneh, haven't played that game in ages but I decided to give it a go tonight. Downloading patch 1.5 as we speak. Grand game. Has been a big addiction of me.
 
spookymooky said:
1.5? What's been changed added.

This read-me details the main fixes made to the game. Other minor fixes and balances have been carried out.

Campaign Map

- We have fixed the "memory leak" slowdown issue that was seen when playing the campaign map for prolonged periods.
- We have fixed the Naval battles that were not working correctly in version 1.3. AI-controlled factions will now make proper use of ships.
- Saved games from version 1.2 will work in version 1.5. A couple of other problems with saved games have also been fixed to prevent crashes.
- The Gauls can no longer recruit Naked Fanatics as they no longer have farming-related shrines and temples.
- Academy-class buildings now give a law bonus, as they do in the BI expansion pack. These buildings now have uses in cities without governors or generals in residence.
- Only Roman factions can hold Games at an Arena-class building.
- Diplomacy has been "tweaked" so that Roman diplomatic activity is more coherent.
- Fleeing armies can now only flee once after a large battle defeat.

Units

- We have added secondary low-quality sword to the phalanx-capable German Spearman Warband.
- Removed inappropriate officer from Rebel Archer Warband units.
- Reduced hit points for German Berserkers from 3 to 2 (matching those in BI).

Battle Map

- Improvements have been made to prevent men spilling around the base of siege towers.
- There was a pathfinding issue that made river battles very slow. This has been fixed.
- Improvements have been made to the AI when orchestrating Skirmish Maneouvres.
- The AI will now use 'fire at will' with idle units so that they throw pila at nearby enemies.
- The AI will now make a decision about throwing pila before charging into combat based on the location of enemy units.

6chars
 
I've been meaning to buy R:TW and the expansion with christmas money... but i cant find it in shops anywhere, before christmas it was on the shelf !!!
 
Back
Top