Hope it wins. Dunno really doesnt matter. As long as valve made the needed money (money they wanted) its all good. They know we love the game and they know they made the best game of all time.
looks to be between HL2 and GTA:SA on IGN then, since they have already hailed HL2 as the best FPS of all time.....that kinda leaves Halo 2 out in the cold.
still think SA will win though, 3 basically identical games in about 4 years isnt enough for some nerds obviously...
as for Gamespy, its between the big 3 : Halo 2, HL2 and GTA: SA.
I guarantee one of the console titles will win.
as for Gamespot, by their scoring, Chronicles of Riddick is a better shooter than HL2 which im not so sure of - has anyone played it who could tell me?