Pink Floyd - Best and Worst?

[brad92]

So I'm a fanatical Pink Floyd fan. Literally fanatical. So to all the Floyd fans here; what's your favorite and worst Pink Floyd album?

I'd have to say my personal favorite is The Division Bell. That might come as a surprise to some; considering Roger Waters had no part in that album or the one previous. But I honestly believe that it is the best musically.

I'd have to say my personal worst is The Final Cut. Far too much emphasis on the lyrics I think. I do love The Gunner's Dream though. Felt too much like The Wall Part 2 to be honest.

What's say you?

 

[knut]

Best: Animals

Worst: I don't actually have one. I don't think DOSTM is all it's cracked up to be, but it has it's moments towards the end (when Roger takes stage, heh heh!) and I wouldn't consider it their worst. Ummm. I'm not actually sure. Not a huge fan of the early Syd stuff, I'll admit.

 

[Iron Kat]

I really like The Division Bell. I don't think any of the albums are particularly bad although I thin the Wall is slightly depressing! There's only one song I really, really, REALLY loathe and that's Bike.

 

[-Kashmir-]

Best: totally Animals.

The Division Bell.. just didn't cut it with me. It didn't have the charm that other Pink Floyd records had. There's just something about it.

 

[xombine]

Pretty cliched but Dark Side of the Moon is the greatest album to listen to while high EVER. "Speak to Me/Breath" into "On the Run" is one of the best musical experiences you can have.

 

[Dinkleberry]

Best: Toss up between Piper at the Gates and DSOTM
I don't like Waters solo stuff at all so I guess I wouldn't like Final Cut either.

 

[99.vikram]

Favourite: The Final Cut

Worst: The Division Bell