General Disscussion still a hell hole

Tr0n

Newbie
Joined
Jun 25, 2003
Messages
9,929
Reaction score
0
Ok I decied to make a thread about the General discussion forum.Please give your suggestions on ways that the mods/admins can improve it.This is meant to be serious.

Here is my suggestion.Get a some mods that live in america so that there will be a moderator present when the mods in europe go to bed or work.
 
I also suggest that munro get rid of that guest account thingy.
 
Holy crap! I just noticed the quick reply is back! Anyways, yeah it's melting pot in there. Full of random people joining and suddenly spamming the forum with pointless threads or racist comments.

It's a circus out there.
 
he wasn't a guest reply thing... his accoutn was deleted...which made the wired names.
 
Tr0n, guest posting has never been allowed on these forums, you might've seen one guest earlier, because thats what happens when the user is deleted (all their posts revert to 'guest'), and about a minute after that, the thread was deleted.

I've been doing my best to clear up the general forum tonight :)
 
StarMonkey could sure use some help in general.... *cough* *wink* *kick*


:)
 
I think they turned it on by accident and that's how the Hitler guy got through
 
I still have faith in 'General Discussion'. See the lastest sticky for evidence (the Valve tour one).
 
heh...yea being a moderator has its peaks im sure. i dont think i post enough or am well known enough to become moderator, although i would like to. back in may i requested it but munro didnt think he needed help...then all the sudden people get it. eh its ok i could understand why he might not want a southern californian moderator. :P

oh wut was this thread about? ...ah yes general forum, to many n00b threads and not enough input on the real stuff. to much crapy commentary. mod are doin a good job though, give em some credit.
 
As soon as more concrete information is released, General discussion will become more of a discussion forum than a comment forum, after all with the small amount of info valve are releasing publicly there is only so much people can talk about until it gets repeated and repeated and repeated and repeated......
 
i believe i should be mod because telling a bunch of headcrabs to stfu and that they're idiots is becoming old and tiresome, it'd be easier to just ban them all :D
 
It's not an easy bloody job, I'll tell you that. I must be moving, commenting on or closing something every 10 seconds :/
 
Wavelength uses a MEMBER+ only group to discuss heated topics. Only people who have shown themselves to be responsible in posting for a while are giving MEMBER+ status. This gives them access to two restricted forums where the typical "flame" topic can be discussed without idiots turning it into pissing wars. Sensitive topics are not allowed in the General Discussion. Any "mature" topic is moved into the restricited space.

It works pretty well there. Threads do get long and heated. (100+ replies). The longest ones get closed if it isnt going anywhere constructive. Racism, Homophonias, Religion, Abortion, politics...all get discussed but they don't become flame wars with people posting for the sake of upping their post count.

The biggest problem here is that there are TOO many members. I avoided the forums for a few weeks because the place was flooded with new people--and too many were idiots. I actually prefer boards with just a few dozen regulars.
 
I don't like the eliteist tone of it... but it might work.

Well, off topic used to have serious discussion... :(
 
Back
Top